The Scene Is Broken but Not Dead: Is This Really Goodbye for Broken Social Scene?

Broken Social Scene

A few of Broken Social Scene's members

Tuesday night marked a sad moment for many Canadians, including myself, and people from around the world as one of Canada’s largest musical exports and arguably one of the most important Canadian bands of the last decade called it quits. Broken Social Scene’s concert in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on November 8th turned out to be their very last as they announced it both at the show and via twitter. Broken Social Scene’s impact has been monumental musically, but they will be forever remembered for the work they put in to fostering an amazing community of Canadian artists including the likes of Feist and Metric. But is it really goodbye forever? Perhaps, but the spirit of Broken Social Scene may be harder to kill than that.

The Community

When Broken Social Scene, founded by Kevin Drew and Brendan Canning, emerged with their largely instrumental 2001 debut, Feel Good Lost, they did so with a distinctly Canadian flavour that in many ways defined them as a band. In fact, the first track on the album was named, in a characteristically tongue in cheek manner, “I Slept With Bonhomme at the CBC.” The live shows they played in support of this album also marked the beginning of their history of collaborations. This tendency toward collaboration and community led to them becoming affiliated with bands and artists such as: Leslie Feist (Feist), Jason Collett, Elizabeth Palmer (Land of Talk), Emily Haines and James Shaw (Metric), Stars, Do Make Say Think, Jason Tait (The Weakerthans) and many, many more. Collaboration and community became such an integral part of the band’s identity that they were often fond of calling themselves a “collective” of musicians. Their laundry list of musical involvement with other Canadian artists often reads like a who’s-who of Canadian indie rock. This is part of the reason why they are different than any other Canadian band for me. Take Arcade Fire, for example. When somebody says to me, “I love Arcade Fire,” my gut reaction is often, “so what?” Saying you love Arcade Fire is like saying you love the Smiths. Everybody loves the Smiths. But when I hear somebody say, “I love Broken Social Scene,” that is a completely different matter. There is a connection there that speaks to the very heart of what it means to be a Canadian artist. Broken Social Scene constitutes a kind of glue that binds Canada’s diverse music scene together. Their existence was and is a testament to the independent spirit that says truly independent artists can make it by sticking together and cooperating. There’s something essentially Canadian in the idea that diverse people can come together to create something new. It is also the reason why their spirit, musically and perhaps physically, will carry on.

Broken Social Scene performs “World Sick,” “7/4 Shoreline,” and “Fire Eye’d Boy” live at SXSW with a 13-person lineup.

 The Future

Part hippy collective and part jam band with a line-up that has expanded to as many as 17  musicians, Broken Social Scene has been defined by their fluctuating nature as a band. As long-time “member” (that word is in quotations because it doesn’t have much meaning when applied to Broken Social Scene) Leslie Feist put it, “Broken Social Scene will be a band when we’re old and grey, even if it’s just at pot luck, because it was never something that needed to be defined.” People like Canning and Drew don’t just stop making music. It’s quite possible, and even likely, that they will be back in one form or another, and it will still be Broken Social Scene.

Whether the start of a hiatus or really the end, Broken Social Scene’s influence will carry on far beyond their physical presence as a band.

Here are some BSS classics for your listening pleasure:

Broken Social Scene – Fire Eye’d Boy

Broken Social Scene – Meet Me in the Basement

Broken Social Scene – Anthems for a Seventeen-Year-Old Girl

One thought on “The Scene Is Broken but Not Dead: Is This Really Goodbye for Broken Social Scene?

  1. I was in the last two shows of Broken Social Scene and they were awesome! I dreamed a lot from the day that one would see them live and I was honored that they made the “last” show here.

    I completely agree when you say “But when I hear somebody say, “I love Broken Social Scene,” that is a completely different matter”. Broken Social Scene is unlike anything I’ve ever heard before. It’s one thing I can not explain. The way the songs were played on the “last” show in Rio de Janeiro is inexplicable. The feeling, happiness, you could see clearly see these and other feelings in the band. I really do not like to cry in public, but for “Pacific Theme”, which ended the show, it was impossible to hold back tears. So many feelings together in the happiest day of my life.

    I had the pleasure to discover that besides being a wonderful band, they are wonderful people. They were attentive to all the fans I spoke with most of the band in the two concerts, they are amazing!

    I’m going to miss the band but this is not the end, is a hiatus – and I believe that. And as you said, they have many bands, working with music and will soon be playing again.

    (I apologize for my English, I do not speak it very well)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s